Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not.

Yamalian yawns

realclimate.org 11 May '12, 10am

Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not.

Second, the unpublished work in question is a reconstruction of regional temperatures from the region of Yamal in Siberia. Regional reconstructions are generally more worthwhile than reconstructions from a single site because, if there is shared variance, the regional result is likely to be more robust and be more representative – and that makes it more valuable for continental and hemispheric comparisons. The key issues are whether all the trees (or some subset of them) share a common signal (are they mostly temperature sensitive? are some localities anomalous? etc.). It isn’t as simple as just averaging all the trees in a grid box or two. The history of such efforts follows a mostly standard path – local chronologies are put together, different ‘standardisation’ techniques are applied, more data is collected, wider collations are put together, and then regional reconstru...

Full article: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2012/05/yam...

Tweets

@DRTucker » 13 May '12, 11am
Yamalian yawns [link]
@RealClimate » 13 May '12, 12am
Yamalian yawns [link]
@GarethSJones1 » 12 May '12, 4pm
RealClimate's take on more "sceptic" recent tree ring claims [link]
@climateinfo » 12 May '12, 1am
Yamalian yawns - Steve McIntyre is free to do any analysis he wants on any data he can find. But when he ladles his ... [link]
@softgrasswalker » 11 May '12, 7pm
Zap! Ka-Pow! Unghhh! Great smackdown of a conspiracy-minded critic: [link] #unmuzzlescience or else!
@WSAZBrandon » 11 May '12, 6pm
If it weren't for Jupiter, our solar system might have had another planet [link] the story of Vesta
@WSAZBrandon » 11 May '12, 4pm
Climate Blog volley continues on Yamal-Urals data: @Realclimate responds [link] to #ClimateAudit's [link]
@constantine_jn » 11 May '12, 3pm
Steve McIntyre, still a dick >> [link]
@Circulator38 » 11 May '12, 2pm
Yamalian yawns: This is of course a classic #conspiracy theory and one that can't be easily… [link]
@SustainNowRadio » 11 May '12, 2pm
#RealClimate takes on Stephen McIntyre's fishing and harassment. Yawn is right. [link]
@MichaelEMann » 11 May '12, 1pm
We comment at #RealClimate on Stephen McIntyre and co.'s increasingly dishonest attacks on climate science/scientists [link]
@SouBundanga » 11 May '12, 1pm
RT @SMEasterbrook: Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not. [link]
@SMEasterbrook » 11 May '12, 1pm
Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not. [link]
@EarthKnowledge » 11 May '12, 1pm
Real Climate: Yamalian yawns: Steve McIntyre is free to do any analysis he wants on any data he can find. But when... [link]
@SouBundanga » 11 May '12, 12pm
RT @AGW_Prof: #McIntyre, #Watts, Bishop Hill. Children scolded yet againat RC. [link] #yamal
@AGW_Prof » 11 May '12, 12pm
#McIntyre, #Watts, Bishop Hill. Children scolded yet againat RC. [link] #yamal
@palaeoisotopes » 11 May '12, 12pm
RT @mammuthus: Climate controversy! Unethical behaviour! Cover up! Scandal! Heroic outsider takes on the system! Or not [link]
@yomekoyoko » 11 May '12, 12pm
Yamalian yawns: Places that are remote (like Yamal) have the advantage of a lack of local human interference, an... [link]
@mammuthus » 11 May '12, 12pm
Climate controversy! Unethical behaviour! Cover up! Scandal! Heroic outsider takes on the system! Or not [link]
@thirstygecko » 11 May '12, 11am
Gavin at Realclimate: 'it is clear Montford’s talents lie in the direction of fiction, not documentary work.' [link]
@carbonmeme » 11 May '12, 11am
Yamalian yawns. Gavin Schmidt responds to Steve McIntyre [link]
@Geoblogfeed » 11 May '12, 11am
Yamalian yawns [link]
@Climate_Change » 11 May '12, 11am
Yamalian yawns: Steve McIntyre is free to do any analysis he wants on any data he can find. But when he ladles h... [link]
@topsciencenews » 11 May '12, 11am
#Real_Climate Yamalian yawns: Steve McIntyre is free to do any analysis he wants on any data he can find. But wh... [link]
@Enviro_Jon » 11 May '12, 10am
✪ Yamalian yawns: Steve McIntyre is free to do any analysis he wants on any data he can find. But when he ladle... [link]
@GarethSJones1 » 12 May '12, 5pm
RT @SMEasterbrook: Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not. [link]
@scottstgeorge » 11 May '12, 1pm
RT @SMEasterbrook: Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not. [link]
@uppsalainit » 11 May '12, 1pm
RT @SMEasterbrook: Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not. [link]
@EileenOttawa » 11 May '12, 1pm
RT @SMEasterbrook: Open Science is a great idea when everyone acting in good faith. It's impossible when they are not. [link]
@casper_jack316 » 11 May '12, 12pm
Yamalian yawns: Steve McIntyre is free to do any analysis he wants on any data he can find. But when he ladles h... [link]
@EileenOttawa » 11 May '12, 12pm
RT @AGW_Prof: #McIntyre, #Watts, Bishop Hill. Children scolded yet againat RC. [link] #yamal