06 Sep '11, 3pm

Resignations, retractions and the process of science

Of course, Spencer does not see this in the same light at all. His comments both before the publication of the paper and subsequent to the editor’s resignation indicate that he thinks that he is being persecuted by (unnamed) ‘IPCC Gatekeepers’ who are conspiring to suppress his results – he even insists that this was “one damn fine and convincing paper “. As well as straining credulity to the maximum, I find this both unfortunate and curious. It is unfortunate because this attitude makes it almost impossible for him to take on board constructive criticism, and given that none of us are perfect, there are many times when doing so is essential. It is also curious because there is no evidence of any grand conspiracy, just people disagreeing with and criticising his conclusions (which as a scientist, you really just have to get used to!). It was S&B’s desire to avoid dealing w...

Full article: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2011/09/res...

Tweets

Why Questionable "Science" Gets Published, Poun...

desmogblog.com 06 Sep '11, 2pm

An editor resigns after a journal publishes a paper that seems to trash the scientific consensus on climate change—but is ...

Journal editor resigns over 'fundamentally flaw...

skepticalscience.com 04 Sep '11, 2pm

Journal editor resigns over 'fundamentally flawed' paper by Roy Spencer Posted on 3 September 2011 by John Cook Professor ...

Journal editor resigns over 'fundamentally flaw...

skepticalscience.com 03 Sep '11, 2am

Journal editor resigns over 'fundamentally flawed' paper by Roy Spencer Posted on 3 September 2011 by John Cook Professor ...

Why Roy Spencer's paper was so wrong

skepticalscience.com 29 Aug '11, 5am

Spencer's Misdiagnosis of Surface Temperature Feedback Posted on 3 August 2011 by Kevin Trenberth This is a re-post of an ...

Public Comment: Phase II of Public Comments Pro...

icann.org 31 Aug '11, 6pm

ICANN Staff requests community feedback concerning implementation plans [PDF, 876 KB] for three specific Accountability an...